MLB Preview And Prediction: New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays Betting Tips & Picks September 7, 2025

Pick Based On Odds: to secure the win

• Analyzing the odds for points scored implies there is a 79.81% expectation of this match having more than 5.5 total points scored:
  Match Over 5.5 Points → 1.25

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (5.5)
  Over	79.81 %
  Under	25.64 %
  Above is calculated from odds. Login now to reveal our expert picks.

• Evaluating the odds for points scored suggests there is a 41.84% prediction of this game having higher than 9.5 total points:
  Match Over 9.5 Points → 2.39

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (9.5)
  Over	41.84 %
  Under	61.69 %
  Above is implied from odds. Login now to find out our expert predictions.

• Derived from the bookies odds, Toronto Blue Jays are favored to cover the -1.5 handicap including extra innings in this fixture, with a 60.94% probability of doing so. A reliable forecast? Most likely, because Sportsbooks have their metrics figured out:
  New York Yankees -1.5 Handicap → 2.37
  Toronto Blue Jays -1.5 Handicap → 1.64

  Prediction	Chance Of Handicap (incl. EI) (-1.5)
  New York Yankees	42.19 %
  Toronto Blue Jays	60.94 %
  Above is calculated from odds. Login now to get our expert predictions.

• Evaluating the odds for total points implies a likelihood of a 100% expectation of this game having more than 4.5 total points scored:
  Match Over 4.5 Points → 1.00

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (4.5)
  Over	100 %
  Under	100 %
  Above is calculated from odds. Login now to reveal our expert picks.

• Derived from the bookies odds, Draw are the favorite to win after the first inning in this game with a 54.64% probability of leading. A solid prediction? We think so, as Bookies produce sharp predictions:
  New York Yankees First Inning → 3.39
  Toronto Blue Jays First Inning → 4.51
  Draw First Inning → 1.83

  Prediction	Chance Of 1st Inning Result
  New York Yankees	29.5 %
  Toronto Blue Jays	22.17 %
  Draw	54.64 %
  Above is calculated from odds. Login now to find out our expert predictions.

To explore value bets so you can win big, check out our in-depth Baseball predictions at Matchstat.com. Unlock today’s winning Baseball value bets here.

H2H-Based Prediction: Toronto Blue Jays to triumph

H2H: Toronto Blue Jays (7 – 3) New York Yankees.
Toronto Blue Jays to win. Why? For the most recent 10 direct encounters between these teams, Toronto Blue Jays lead 7 – 3. Our head to head analysis starts from the encounter they had in 2003. This implies that Toronto Blue Jays are likely to get the victory in this upcoming face-off. The latest match between them happened on the Sat, 06 Sept 25, where New York Yankees got a 3 – 1 win.

Can New York Yankees break the pattern and overcome the H2H stats? The most recent match New York Yankees came out on top vs Toronto Blue Jays occurred on Sat, 06 Sept 25, indicating that they are not without hope.

Current Form Prediction: New York Yankees to prevail

Considering recent form before this match, New York Yankees triumphed versus Toronto Blue Jays with a result of 3-1. Toronto Blue Jays lost vs New York Yankees with a score of 1-3. New York Yankees have triumphed in 7 of their recent 10 matches in all competitions, whereas Toronto Blue Jays got the victory in 5 of their last 10 games against all teams, indicating perhaps New York Yankees have an edge heading into this match.

New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays Best Betting Odds For The Fixture

Winner (incl. extra innings)

1W

1.662

2W

2.36

Over Under (incl. extra innings)

> 5.5

1.253

< 5.5

3.9

> 9.5

2.39

< 9.5

1.621

> 4.5

1

< 4.5

1

Handicap (incl. extra innings) && -1.5

1W -1.5

2.37

2W -1.5

1.641

First Inning Result

1W

3.39

2W

4.51

X

1.83

New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays Tips

First Inning Result → Draw appears a valuable gamble → 1.83